The Buffalo nickel is one of the best-loved designs in American coinage. A Native American profile on the front and a bison on the back, struck from 1913 to 1938, it looks nothing like the coins around it. It is also the design behind our Buffalo Nickel copper round. This guide covers who made it, what is on it, why so many are worn smooth, and what to look for if you find one.
The short version
| Designer | James Earle Fraser |
|---|---|
| Struck | 1913 to 1938, by the U.S. Mint |
| Replaced | The Liberty Head ("V") nickel |
| Replaced by | The Jefferson nickel, in 1938 |
| Metal | 75% copper, 25% nickel |
| Size | About 5 grams and 21 mm across |
Who designed it, and why it looks different
James Earle Fraser was a sculptor who had trained under Augustus Saint-Gaudens, the artist behind some of the most admired U.S. coins of the early 1900s. The Mint was redesigning its coins in those years, and the nickel was due for a change. Fraser's answer was to put distinctly American subjects on a coin that, until then, had carried a Liberty head and a Roman numeral.
The front shows a Native American in profile, with the word LIBERTY and the date. The back shows an American bison, with UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, E PLURIBUS UNUM and FIVE CENTS. Fraser said he based the profile on several Native American men rather than one. Accounts differ on which, so be wary of any single name you see attached to the portrait.
Buffalo or bison?
The animal is an American bison. "Buffalo" is the everyday name for it in the United States, and the coin has been called the Buffalo nickel ever since. The best-known story says the model was a bison called Black Diamond at a New York zoo, but accounts differ on that too, and Fraser may have worked from more than one animal.
Two reverses in the first year
The coin changed within months of its release. On the first version, called Type 1, the bison stands on a raised mound with FIVE CENTS written on it. That wording sat on the highest point of the coin and wore away quickly in pockets and tills. The Mint lowered the mound and moved FIVE CENTS into a recessed area beneath it. That is Type 2, and every later Buffalo nickel uses it.
| Type 1 (early 1913) | Type 2 (1913 onward) | |
|---|---|---|
| Bison stands on | A raised mound | A flattened line |
| FIVE CENTS | On the mound, where it wore off | In a recess below |
| How common | One year only | The rest of the series |
Why so many have no date
If you have ever held a Buffalo nickel with a smooth patch where the year should be, that is normal. The date sits on a raised part of the design that takes the most wear, so a lot of them are worn down to "dateless" after decades in circulation. A dateless nickel is usually worth little more than a common one, but look at the back before you decide: the mint mark below FIVE CENTS often survives when the date does not.
Mint marks and dates worth a second look
The mint mark is on the back, below FIVE CENTS. No letter means Philadelphia, D means Denver and S means San Francisco. A few Buffalo nickels are scarce enough that collectors look for them:
- 1913-S Type 2. A low-mintage San Francisco coin from the first year.
- 1916 doubled die. The date and lettering on the front show a clear doubling, because the die was struck twice slightly out of line.
- 1918/7-D. An overdate, where a 1918 die was cut over a 1917 one.
- 1921-S and 1926-S. Low-mintage San Francisco dates.
- 1937-D "three-legged." A die was polished so hard that the bison lost a front leg, and a few coins were struck from it.
Condition matters as much as the date, and prices move, so check a current price guide or ask a dealer before you assume anything. If you have a nickel you think is special, do not clean it: cleaning scratches the surface and reduces what a collector will pay.
From a five-cent coin to a copper round
Our Buffalo Nickel round takes its profile and the word LIBERTY from the front of Fraser's coin. The Buffalo Nickel bar carries a bison in the style of the back. They are the same design in two shapes. If you are choosing between them, copper bars vs rounds covers the difference.
The round is a different object from the coin it follows:
- It is 1 oz of .999 fine copper, about 28.35 grams, not 5 grams of copper-nickel.
- It is not a nickel, has no face value and was not made by the U.S. Mint.
- It is priced at $6.50, and you can check one at home with a scale and a magnet.
Where we fit in
T&C Coin sells copper rounds and bars in designs that follow classic American coins and notes, with the price and stock shown on every piece and insured, tracked shipping. If you are not sure which design to pick, or want to ask about a coin you have found, Thomas takes calls monday to saturday, 8am to 6pm, on (505) 518-2288.